"Island Life" (1985) Album Description:
"Island Life" is the sort of compilation that looks neat on paper and slightly suspicious in the hand. By December 1985, Grace Jones had already torn through disco, cold-wave chic, reggae tension, nightclub funk, and that grand, expensive Trevor Horn machinery, so any single LP trying to sum her up was bound to leave a few bruises. Still, this one gets away with it more often than not. The running order moves like a hard stare across a decade: "La Vie En Rose" still slinks, "Private Life" still carries that dry, clipped menace, and "Slave to the Rhythm" lands at the end like the room lights just changed without asking permission.
The real hook is that this record lies a little, and not in a bad way. It pretends to be a tidy greatest-hits set, but once the needle drops it turns into something stranger: a document of reinvention by a singer who kept walking into other people's genres, rearranging the furniture, and leaving with the best lamp. Open the rest and the cracks start to matter—the songs left out, the sharp turn from Tom Moulton’s disco floor to Compass Point’s lean muscle, and the way 1985 was already trying to package Grace Jones while she was still too slippery to package properly.
Calling this a simple "best of" misses the grime under its nails. These tracks were cut across very different phases of Jones' career, and you can hear the shifts in production method like changes in weather. The early material still has that disco lift and sweep, elegant but a bit theatrical, while the Compass Point-era cuts hit with more bite and less lipstick: Sly & Robbie’s rhythm sense, Blackwell and Sadkin’s sense of space, guitars that slash instead of decorate, and basslines that move like they know the back door as well as the front.
That is where the album earns its keep. "Pull Up to the Bumper," "Walking in the Rain," and "My Jamaican Guy" don’t just sound good next to one another; they show how Jones stopped being treated like a stylish disco object and became the controlling presence in the room. Not warmer. Not softer. Just more dangerous. Plenty of 1985 pop was going glossy by default—Madonna going for mass seduction, Eurythmics sharpening synth-pop into a clean blade, Sade drifting on poise, Talking Heads turning neurosis into sleek rhythm science. Jones, meanwhile, still sounded like she might laugh at the whole industry and then walk off with its best tune.
The Jamaican angle matters, even if this record is no roots set and never pretends to be one. In 1985, Jamaican music at home was pushing deeper into digital dancehall, tougher and more stripped, while Jones remained an international creature shaped as much by Paris, New York, and Nassau as by Spanish Town. "My Jamaican Guy" is the clue. It is not a tourist postcard and not some dutiful heritage nod either; it sits inside the compilation like a sly reminder that her accent on record was always chosen, never handed over for easy sorting.
The sleeve adds its own argument. The front image is all impossible geometry and control, Jean-Paul Goude turning Grace into a design problem and then solving it with a razor blade and glue. Flip to the inner material and you get the other half of the story: stage images, masks, poses, cigarettes, the whole constructed mythology laid out like contact sheets from a campaign too smart to call itself a campaign. Handling the LP makes that tension clearer. The record wants to look immaculate, but the print grain, the slight fuzz in smaller text, the spindle wear around the center hole—those little facts keep dragging it back into the real world where records lived on shelves, not in theory.
There was no great public scandal attached to this release, and frankly that tells its own story. The common gripe has always been more collector-ish than dramatic: it smooths the catalog too neatly and skips material some listeners would fight for, especially if they prefer the awkward corners to the polished headline moments. Fair complaint. "Island Life" is not the whole woman. It is the version Island could sell in one sleeve after "Slave to the Rhythm" had kicked the door open.
Late at night this record makes more sense than it does in daylight. The best copies always seem to come from bins where the sleeve has just enough ring rub to prove somebody actually lived with it, and that feels right because Grace Jones was never background music for tidy people.
As a listening experience, Side One still feels a touch more curated than lived, almost like the label trying to clear its throat before the better material arrives. Side Two is where the blood circulation improves. "Love Is the Drug" has snap, "Pull Up to the Bumper" still struts like it owns the pavement, and "Slave to the Rhythm" closes the set with enough pomp to make the whole compilation seem grander than it really is. A bit of a cheat, yes. A smart one.
So no, this is not the last word on Grace Jones. It is too selective, too strategic, too keen to turn a restless career into a handsome object. But as a 1985 snapshot of what made her impossible to shelve beside the ordinary pop acts, it works. Not because it explains her. Because it doesn’t quite manage to.