"Innocence Is No Excuse" (1985) Album Description:
"Innocence Is No Excuse" catches Saxon in 1985 with one boot still in the NWOBHM yard and the other slipping, rather suspiciously, onto a cleaner EMI floor. This is their seventh studio album, their first after moving away from Carrere Records, and the last Saxon studio LP with Steve Dawson on bass. The old steel-toecap charge is still there, but now it has polish on it, and polish is where metal fans start sharpening knives.
The interesting bit is not whether the record is heavy enough. That argument is too easy, and usually shouted by blokes who have already made up their minds. The better question is what happens when a band built on road sweat, denim, leather, and blunt-force choruses tries to sound bigger, brighter, and more radio-ready without completely losing the smell of the rehearsal room. Open the sleeve and the answer is awkward, glossy, occasionally daft, and much more listenable than the grumblers like to admit.
Britain in 1985 was not waiting politely for Saxon to return from the road. Iron Maiden had already become arena machinery, Def Leppard had shown every label accountant that British hard rock could be buffed until it reflected money, Motörhead were still grinning through the grime, Raven were pushing into a speedier metallic scramble, and Tank kept the pub-fight end of the street warm. Saxon were no longer the scrappy new gang at the bar. They were veterans with expectations hanging round their necks like a wet denim jacket.
That pressure leaks into the grooves. "Rockin’ Again" opens with a big, squared-up chorus rather than a dirty back-alley ambush, and "Call of the Wild" has the sort of hard-rock lift that wants lights, not fog. "Back on the Streets" is where the crossover itch really starts scratching: clean attack, roomy chorus, guitars less like a factory saw and more like a machine being demonstrated to people in suits. Annoying? A little. Effective? Unfortunately, yes.
The record was produced and recorded by Simon Hanhart at Union Studios in Munich, with mixing credited to Hanhart and Saxon at Wisseloord Studios in Hilversum. That geography matters more than it looks. The sound is not the cramped British club charge of "Wheels of Steel" or "Strong Arm of the Law"; it has wider shoulders, brighter edges, and a studio gloss that can make the riffs feel cleaner than some listeners wanted. The guitars still bite, but the bite has been polished. There’s the crime scene.
Biff Byford remains the chief weapon, because he can still turn a chorus into a roomful of raised fists even when the writing leans toward crowd-control slogans. Graham Oliver and Paul Quinn keep the twin-guitar engine moving, less savage than the early days but still sharp enough when the arrangements stop posing. Steve Dawson’s bass does its old job without waving a flag, holding the middle while Nigel Glockler gives the album a cleaner, firmer stomp than Pete Gill’s earlier rivet-gun attack. Wrong drummer listed on old copy? Easy trap. The label and sleeve point to Glockler here.
"Broken Heroes" is the keeper for me. Not because it is the heaviest thing here — it is not — but because it slows the room down and gives the album some actual weight beyond the usual hands-in-the-air business. There is drag in it, a little grief under the chorus, and Saxon sound less like they are auditioning for American radio and more like they have found a bruise worth pressing. That one earns its place.
The rest swings between sturdy heavy metal and big-chorus hard rock with the occasional eyebrow-raiser. "Everybody Up" and "Gonna Shout" are not exactly subtle philosophical documents, unless one’s philosophy was written on a beer mat ten minutes before closing time. Still, Saxon had always understood the ritual side of metal: repetition, chant, lift, release, the crowd becoming part of the engine. When it works, it works like boots on floorboards. When it doesn’t, it sounds like somebody from EMI smiled too much in the control room.
Scene Pressure, Label Polish, And The Usual Accusations
No grand public scandal clings to "Innocence Is No Excuse", no banned sleeve panic, no tabloid bonfire, no moral guardian waving the album around like evidence. The controversy was more domestic and more useful: fans arguing whether Saxon had softened up for a wider market. That accusation has some teeth, but it also gets lazy. Cleaner production is not automatically betrayal, though heavy metal fans do enjoy treating a reverb plate like a war crime.
The bigger misconception is the dating and line-up muddle that trails this album around like a bad merch-table receipt. It belongs to 1985, not 1986, with the EMI/Parlophone issue and the label text backing that up. It is also not Saxon’s twelfth studio album, and Graham Oliver was not some new arrival here; he was part of the original machinery. By this point the band had already gone through the Pete Gill-to-Nigel Glockler drum change after the early classic run, and Dawson’s exit after this album would make the next chapter feel even less settled.
The sleeve tells the same story in cardboard. The front cover goes for glossy temptation: a close-up face, a green apple, Saxon’s logo stamped into the fruit, all very mid-80s and very pleased with itself. The back cover adds the boot, the apple, track list, credits, barcode, and the cold little business marks that always drag fantasy back to the stockroom. Then the custom inner sleeve does the useful work: band photos, lyrics, credits, and enough printed matter to make the LP feel like a proper object, not just a disc shoved into a paper bag. Bless the custom inner sleeve. It earns its rent.
The record label adds its own collector nudge: EMI and Parlophone branding, catalogue number 1C 064-24 0400 1, LC 0299, GEMA and STEMRA rights boxes, "Seite 1", and "Made in EEC" sitting in the rim text. That is the sort of small print that keeps collectors hunched over a desk lamp at midnight, pretending this is normal behaviour. Been there. The apple on the sleeve shouts; the label quietly tells the truth.
Heard late at night, not too loud but loud enough to annoy the wall, the album feels less like a sell-out than a band trying to outrun the narrowing lane they had helped pave. The attack is tidier, the choruses are broader, the chrome is polished, and yes, some of the old road dirt has been wiped off. But Saxon had not turned into wallpaper. They were just trying to survive 1985 without being eaten by bands younger, faster, slicker, uglier, prettier, or better financed. Rock and roll, as ever, remained a charmingly unfair racket.
So no, "Innocence Is No Excuse" is not the rawest Saxon LP, and anyone saying otherwise has either lost the plot or bought the wrong record. It is a transitional heavy metal album with hooks, gloss, bruises, and a few slightly embarrassing crowd-bait moments. That makes it human. More importantly for the shelf, it marks a real fault line in the Saxon story: Carrere grit behind them, EMI polish under their boots, Steve Dawson about to leave, and the old NWOBHM certainties beginning to look less certain by the week.
References
- Vinyl Records and Album Cover Gallery: Saxon "Innocence Is No Excuse" high-resolution album photos and page context
- Official Saxon Biography
- MusicBrainz release group: Saxon "Innocence Is No Excuse"
- MusicBrainz release data and production annotation
- Discogs master release: Saxon "Innocence Is No Excuse"